Teen 2004 - Melissa Pierce
Mrs. 2004 - Allison Hirschmann
Teen 2005 - Veronika Pashkin
Miss 2005 - Makini Young
Mrs 2005 - Lori Stangl

Teen 2006 - Jenna Knopsnyder
Miss 2006 - Kelly Sivec
Mrs. 2006 - Cheryl Cameron
Teen 2007 - Amber Marlowe
Miss 2007 - Yasmine Shaffie

Mrs. 2007 - Deborah Wright
Teen 2008 - Kathryn McDonnell
Miss 2008 - Ashley Borchilo
Mrs. 2008 - Susan Huntley
Miss 2009 - Jordyn Colao

Mrs. 2009 - Sheri Jenkins
Teen 2010 - Sophia Medairy
Miss 2010 - Tammie Kennedy
Mrs. 2010 - Dixie Shaffer
Teen 2011 - Kaitlyn Lucas

Miss 2011 - Julia Pauline
Mrs. 2011 - Dawn Hicks
Teen 2012 - Julianne Biddle
Miss 2012 - Kelsey Landy
Mrs. 2012 - Kimberly McLendon

Teen 2013 - Ashlee Fagans
Miss 2013 - Rachel Syktich
Mrs. 2013 - Marci McNair
Teen 2014 - Brielle Corrente
Miss 2014 - Amanda Pope

Mrs. 2014 - Nicole Froats
Teen 2015 - Mary Honkus
Miss 2015 - Kailey Verbickey
Mrs. 2015 - Cheryl Schrier
Teen 2016 - Madison Kunst

Miss 2016 - Sherri Homanko
Mrs. 2016 - Erin Landis
Teen 2017 - Leigha Pertz
Miss 2017 - Kaitlyn Lucas
Mrs. 2017 - Amanda Leber